Officers and survivors partner to prevent parole for Ohio cop killer

On January 21, 1987, a 22-year-old police officer for the Village of Morrow, Ohio named Jeffrey Manning Phegley was shot and killed in the line of duty while performing a traffic stop.

Anthony Wayne McIntosh was convicted of the murder of Officer Phegley later that same year and was sentenced to 15-years-to-life, with an additional three years for using a gun during the commission of his crime. McIntosh has once been denied parole by the Central Office Review Board of the Ohio Adult Parole Authority, but he is again being considered for parole.

PoliceOne Columnist Lt. Dan Marcou, in his excellent column written in response to the murder of four Oakland police officers earlier this year, called parole “a national game of Russian Roulette.”

“Lovelle Mixon,” Marcou wrote, “is a prime example of that flawed system. He was placed in prison for armed robbery and assault with a deadly weapon. He was released on parole, put back in prison for parole violation, and then released again. Once again, he violated his parole and was wanted on a no-bail warrant for parole violation. He was stopped in East Oakland at 1:08 PM on Saturday, March 21, 2009 by motorcycle officers Sgt. Mark Dunakin and Officer John Hege.”

Marcou wrote that when parole boards all over the country release the Mixon’s of the world, it’s almost as if they simply load a round into the cylinder, spin it, and then hand the weapon over to their communities. “Every cop that makes a traffic stop hopes they are not walking up on a live cylinder as these officers did,” Marcou wrote.

In an e-mail we received this week, Ohio COPS President Sara Winfield said, “We need your help. Please take a few minutes to sign the petition, write a personal letter, or sign the attached form letter, requesting that Inmate McIntosh’s parole be again denied, and that he be required to serve his life sentence.”

According to Winfield, McIntosh apparently said during his 2000 parole hearing that he didn’t expect to get parole that time because he killed a cop, but that he thought he’d get out in five years. “The parole board answered that bold statement when he was given an additional 10 years before his next hearing, the hearing that he is now up for,” Winfield wrote.

In a letter dated September 8, 2009 Barb and Joe Phegley — the parents of Patrolman Jeffrey Phegley — said that the effort to keep Inmate McIntosh locked up is a daunting task. “We cannot do it alone and must rely on the kindness and generosity of family, friends, concerned citizens, and even total strangers to assist us. Anything you can do to help us keep him in prison to serve his life sentence would be greatly appreciated.”

So, what can you do? You can print out this petition and pass it around your squad room, or you can print out and sign this form letter — either or both of which may then be sent to the Parole Board. Anyone wishing to write a personal letter instead of using the form letter is encouraged to do so.

You can also add your comments below this article — we will compile them and send them all in a single bundle.

Your correspondence may be mailed directly to the Parole board:

Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections
Office of Victim Services
Attn: Parole Board
770 W Broad St.
Columbus, Ohio 43222-1419

If you wish, you can address your correspondence to the Parole Board but mail it to PoliceOne — we’ll collect those and send them to Barb and Joe Phegley for forwarding to the Parole Board in a single package.

Finally, you can choose to send protests via e-mail at [email protected].

Please be advised that the deadline for your letters, petitions, and e-mails is November 15th and that all correspondence must include the following information on each page:

• Inmate’s name and prison number: Anthony Wayne McIntosh, Inmate No. A198370
• Victim’s name, occupation, age: Jeffrey Manning Phegley, Patrolman, Morrow, Ohio Police Dept. Age 22.
• Date of crime: January 21, 1987

Previous Post

Sheriff Joe stripped of ICE agent status

Next Post

Idaho cop shot by colleague during gun cleaning

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *